The most widely discussed reason, particularly among fans, for Frodo not verbally addressing Legolas by name during the emotional farewell scenes in The Lord of the Rings is rooted in a popular theory: Frodo simply didn't know Legolas's name.
The "Unknown Name" Theory Explained
Despite their shared perilous journey as members of the Fellowship of the Ring, a specific fan theory suggests that Frodo, the hobbit, never actually learned the full name of the Sindarin Elf, Legolas Greenleaf. This seemingly surprising notion stems from observations of their interactions throughout the epic quest. While Frodo had extensive direct dialogue and close relationships with other companions like Sam, Gandalf, Aragorn, and even Merry and Pippin, his exchanges with Legolas were notably less frequent and often more formal or indirect.
The theory posits that by the time of the final farewells, after all they had endured together, Frodo would have been too embarrassed to admit he didn't know the name of one of his integral companions. This awkwardness or shame, rather than any lack of affection or respect, is believed to be the reason for his silence or more general farewell gestures towards Legolas, as opposed to explicitly calling out his name as he might have done for others. This interpretation highlights a subtle, human element within the grand narrative, suggesting that even heroes can face relatable social discomforts.
This theory offers a nuanced explanation for a moment that might otherwise seem an oversight or a subtle slight, attributing Frodo's silence to an understandable, if slightly humorous, social predicament.
