Yes, Shae did genuinely love Tyrion at a certain point in their relationship.
Did Shae Ever Love Tyrion?
At a significant juncture in their relationship, Shae genuinely harbored love for Tyrion Lannister. This affection was clearly demonstrated through her actions and words, particularly when faced with a pivotal choice that could have drastically altered her life.
Demonstrations of Shae's Affection
Her love for Tyrion was explicitly confirmed when she was presented with an enticing offer by Varys, the Master of Whisperers. Varys, attempting to remove her from King's Landing for her own safety and to protect Tyrion's standing, offered Shae a substantial incentive:
- Refusal of Diamonds: Shae rejected a bag of diamonds and the opportunity to begin a new life across the Narrow Sea. This act underscored her commitment to Tyrion over material wealth or personal security.
- Direct Affirmation: She explicitly stated her love for Tyrion directly to Varys, leaving no ambiguity about her feelings at that time.
The Dynamics of Their Relationship
Their love story unfolded amidst complex and dangerous circumstances within King's Landing. Despite the genuine nature of Shae's feelings, their relationship was consistently challenged by external pressures:
- Secrecy: Their affair had to remain a closely guarded secret due to Tyrion's status and the strict societal norms of Westeros.
- Tyrion's Forced Marriage: The situation became even more precarious with Tyrion being compelled into a political marriage. This development was a significant strain, as it meant Tyrion would inevitably have less time to spend with Shae, creating a difficult reality for both of them.
Shae's unwavering refusal of Varys' generous offer stands as a strong testament to the authentic love she felt for Tyrion, highlighting her loyalty and deep emotional connection to him during that period.
