Archer states that Dieter and Sayid were kidnapped because the Symphony had taken something of significant value from his group. Specifically, Archer was referring to Eleanor, who was intended to be the fifth bride of the prophet.
Understanding Archer's Motivation
The act of kidnapping by Archer and his followers, often referred to as the Prophet's group, stems from a deep-seated grievance and a desire for retribution. The core of Archer's justification lies in the perceived theft or loss of a key individual:
- Eleanor's Significance: Eleanor was designated as the prophet's fifth bride, indicating her crucial role within their community and belief system. Her loss was considered a direct affront and a profound injury to the Prophet's group.
- Retaliation Against the Symphony: The Traveling Symphony, which includes Sayid and Dieter, was targeted because Archer believed they were responsible for or connected to Eleanor's disappearance or abduction. This act of kidnapping was a form of retaliation, an eye for an eye, aiming to recover what they lost or exact a price for it.
The reference specifically highlights the questioning of Archer regarding Sayid's capture, to which Archer explicitly links it to the Symphony having taken Eleanor. Although the reference confirms Dieter's death, his initial capture would have been under the same premise of seeking redress for Eleanor's loss.
