Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) is inherently greater than Biochemical Oxygen Demand (BOD) because it quantifies the total amount of oxygen required for the chemical oxidation of all organic and many inorganic compounds, whereas BOD only measures the oxygen consumed by biodegradable organic matter. This broader scope of COD means it will always encompass and exceed the oxygen demand measured by BOD.
Understanding Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD)
Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) is a measure of the amount of oxygen required to chemically break down both organic and inorganic compounds in a water sample. It utilizes a strong chemical oxidizing agent, such as potassium dichromate, under acidic conditions and high temperatures, to oxidize virtually all organic matter, including those that are resistant to biological degradation.
- Key Characteristics of COD:
- Measures the total oxygen demand from chemical oxidation.
- Includes biodegradable, non-biodegradable, and slowly biodegradable organic compounds.
- Also accounts for reduced inorganic compounds (e.g., sulfides, ferrous iron) that can be chemically oxidized.
- Provides a rapid assessment of total organic pollution (typically hours).
Understanding Biochemical Oxygen Demand (BOD)
Biochemical Oxygen Demand (BOD), conversely, measures the amount of dissolved oxygen consumed by microorganisms during the biological decomposition (biodegradation) of organic matter in a water sample over a specific period, usually five days (BOD5), at a standardized temperature (20°C). It primarily reflects the oxygen demand from biologically active pollutants.
- Key Characteristics of BOD:
- Measures the oxygen demand from biological degradation.
- Only includes biodegradable organic compounds.
- Excludes non-biodegradable organics and most inorganic compounds.
- Requires a longer incubation period (typically 5 days).
The Fundamental Reason: Scope of Measurement
The core reason COD values are consistently higher than BOD values lies in the distinct types of substances each test measures:
-
COD's Comprehensive Scope: The chemical oxidation process used for COD is far more aggressive and comprehensive. It breaks down not only the organic matter that microorganisms can readily consume (biodegradable organics) but also:
- Non-biodegradable organic compounds: These are organic substances that microorganisms cannot easily break down.
- Slowly biodegradable organic compounds: Substances that degrade very slowly over long periods, beyond the typical BOD test duration.
- Reduced inorganic compounds: Certain inorganic substances (like ammonia, nitrites, sulfides, or ferrous iron) can also consume oxygen during chemical oxidation.
-
BOD's Limited Scope: The biological process in BOD is limited by the capabilities of the microorganisms present. They can only decompose organic matter that serves as a food source, and they cannot break down all types of organic compounds or oxidize most inorganic substances effectively within the typical test duration.
Therefore, since COD accounts for a wider array of oxygen-consuming substances—including all the components measured by BOD, plus non-biodegradable organics and oxidizable inorganics—its measured value will always be equal to or greater than BOD.
Comparative Overview: COD vs. BOD
To illustrate the differences clearly, consider the following table:
| Feature | Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) | Biochemical Oxygen Demand (BOD) |
|---|---|---|
| What it measures | Oxygen consumed by chemical breakdown of all organic and many inorganic compounds. | Oxygen consumed by microorganisms decomposing biodegradable organic matter. |
| Compounds included | Biodegradable, non-biodegradable, slowly biodegradable organics, and oxidizable inorganics. | Primarily biodegradable organic compounds. |
| Methodology | Strong chemical oxidants (e.g., potassium dichromate) under acidic, high-temperature conditions. | Biological degradation by naturally occurring microorganisms. |
| Timeframe | Short (results typically within 2–3 hours). | Longer (typically 5 days for BOD5, or up to 20 days for ultimate BOD). |
| Result relative to other | Always equal to or greater than BOD. | Always equal to or less than COD. |
| Primary application | Total organic pollution, operational control, and efficiency of treatment processes. | Biodegradability, impact on dissolved oxygen in receiving waters. |
| Key Advantage | Rapid results for quick process adjustments. | Reflects actual biological impact on aquatic environments. |
Practical Implications and Significance
Both COD and BOD are vital parameters for assessing water quality and managing wastewater:
- Wastewater Treatment Design and Operation:
- COD provides a quick, robust measure of the total organic load entering and leaving a treatment plant. It's crucial for monitoring treatment efficiency and making rapid operational adjustments.
- BOD is essential for designing biological treatment systems, as it indicates the fraction of organic matter that can be effectively removed by microorganisms.
- Wastewater Biodegradability: The ratio of COD to BOD (COD/BOD ratio) is an important indicator of wastewater treatability:
- A low COD/BOD ratio (e.g., 2:1 or less) suggests that the wastewater is largely biodegradable, meaning biological treatment methods will be effective.
- A high COD/BOD ratio (e.g., 5:1 or more) indicates a significant presence of non-biodegradable or slowly biodegradable organic compounds. This might necessitate advanced or physiochemical treatment methods in addition to, or instead of, conventional biological treatment.
- Environmental Monitoring: These parameters help assess the pollution potential of industrial discharges and their impact on natural water bodies. High COD or BOD values can lead to oxygen depletion in rivers and lakes, harming aquatic life.
By understanding that COD measures a broader spectrum of oxygen-consuming substances through chemical means, it becomes clear why its values are consistently higher than those of BOD, which focuses solely on the biologically degradable fraction.
